Thursday, October 27, 2016

Tunnel to the Cloud: pfSense to Azure Site to Site IPsec Connection

Do you have multi-continent datacenters with gobs of bandwidth, IOps, and processing capability? No? I can help get you part of the way there... a network presence in one.

A tunnel.

A Site to Site Connection?


It's easier to think of this as an extension to your network into another datacenter over the internet. Using IPsec we can provide a relatively (comments at the end) secure, direct connection between on on-premises datacenter and Azure hosted resources by encrypting the traffic that flows between the two.  What do I mean by:
  • Secure: IPsec tunnels all your traffic so it is encrypted over the internet; in reality, this is really "more secure" rather than definitively secure, as the effective security depends highly on implementation specifics.
  • Direct: Your router (played by pfSense in this case) will recognize the Azure site as another routable network within the boundaries of your own, enabling you to talk to Azure resources as if they were in your own datacenter.

Note: this works for Amazon Web Services (AWS) as well but is slightly more complex. Fortunately pfSense includes a wizard that works, but takes a lot of the fun out of it as it strips you of understanding how it works. In addition the wizard is necessary because of how Amazon does VPC routing, whereas Azure is a bit more straightforward.

This article will also be useful for non-pfSense devices since we discuss the details of the IPsec tunnel; the information here should be applicable to any IPsec solution.

With that, let's get to it!


Pre-Requisites

  • pfSense firewall(s): The steps in this article were performed on a pair of  HA SG-4860 firewalls running pfSense 2.32p1.
  • Microsoft Azure account with adequate permissions: We'll be performing our actions using the "new" portal based on Azure Resource Manager (ARM or AzureRM).
  • AzureRM PowerShell Cmdlets installed: On Win10/Server 2016 this can be accomplished with Install-Module AzureRM; for more info see this post.

Configure Azure IPSec Endpoint

Before we set up and initiate the connection from pfSense, we need to set up our endpoint in Azure. To do so, we'll create the following objects:
  • A Resource Group
  • A Public IP Address
  • A Virtual Network
  • A Gateway Subnet
  • A Virtual Network Gateway
  • A Local Network Gateway with a Connection

Resource Group

A Resource Group is a logical grouping of Azure Resources. This logical group allows for easy organization and clearer billing reports. We won't get too much into concepts and naming standards here other than to say groups should be logically tied with similar lifecycle expectancies and you should be consistent. For more information, see this Azure article.

Note: We'll be doing most of our steps in the web portal, but this whole process is much more efficient with PowerShell.

Let's go!
  1. Open and log into the ARM Azure Portal at portal.azure.com; ensure you're working with the subscription you intend to use.
  2. Navigate to "Resource Groups".
  3. Click "Add" and type a name for your resource group, select the subscription, and resource group location. Note: The resource group location has no bearing on where you'll be connecting to as it's just a location the metadata is stored.
  4. Click "Save".


Public IP Address

While we could do the IP at the time we make the Virtual Network Gateway, we'll take care of it now to ensure it's provisioned prior to getting to that step and to discuss the IP details.
  1. Navigate to "Public IP addresses".
  2. Click "Add" and populate the following:
    • Name: Select a name leveraging consistent naming standards.
    • IP address assignment: Select "Dynamic". I know what you're saying.. you're saying "but Toby, I'm not saying anything", and what I'm saying is it seems this should be static. Unfortunately if we make a static IP we'll be greeted later with the following:

      Why Azure, WHY?!

      Now I've been running a tunnel straight for almost a month thus far and my dynamic IP has not shifted on me; I suspect it will behave the same as IPs for other resources and stay static so long as it is used. If this does change, you'll need to change the info in the Phase 1 and 2 setup of the tunnel on the pfSense side as outlined below. For the record, as of the writing of this article the pricing of IPs in Azure is a bit odd; dynamic IPs and static IPs beyond the first 5 in any region are charged the same (pretty trivial), while the first 5 static in a region are free. See here for more info.
    • Idle Timeout: The default of 4 minutes should be fine here.
    • DNS Name Label: Optionally, specify a DNS alias here, though we will not reference it again in this guide as I'm not addressing DNS issues associated with IPsec at this time.
    • Subscription: Select your subscription.
    • Resource Group: Click the resource group we created in the last step.
    • Location: The IP is our IPsec target, so select a location close to your local network connection. The Azure Speed Test comes in quite handy here.


  3. Click "Create". This provisioning will take a few minutes minutes as Azure re-arranges its SDN infrastructure to give you an IP.

  4. What a successful deployment looks like!

Virtual Network/Subnet/Gateway Subnet

A "Virtual Network" is a network space within Azure that you can carve up and protect (firewall) to suit your needs. We're required to make one subnet, and we'll create our "gateway subnet" (landing point) as well. If this is your first foray into virtual networks on Azure you may want to take a step back and consider your design before proceeding. Oh, you're back already? Let's go.
  1. Navigate to "Virtual Networks".


  2. Click "Add" and supply the following:
    • Name: Type a name for your Virtual Network; you should follow the naming standards as discussed above.
    • Address Space: This is the overall space for your logical network within Azure. You can create more granular subnets within this space at any time, so erring on the side of a large subnet would be wise. If you're unsure, use 10.1.0.0/16.
    • Subnet Name: You're required to create one subnet within your virtual network off the bat. You need to name it here and ensure you use a consistent and meaningful naming standard.
    • Subnet Address Range: Specify a subnet range within your virtual network. This won't be used by our IPsec connection directly, but we will use it later as a target for testing. If unsure, use 10.1.10.0/24.
    • Subscription: Select your desired subscription.
    • Resource Group: Select "Use Existing" and select the resource group we created earlier.
    • Location: Select the same location used for the IP above. 


  3. After the Virtual Network has been created (use the refresh key if necessary), click it to navigate to the next pane, and then click "Subnets".


  4. On the next pane, click "+ Gateway Subnet". And specify a subnet in "Address Range". This subnet needs to be different than the one we created earlier and should not be used for non-network resources, but rather as an ingress point to your Virtual Network. If unsure, use 10.1.0.0/24.


Virtual Network Gateway

The "Virtual Network Gateway" is our configuration element that facilitates the IPsec tunnel. Microsoft refers to this as a "VPN" gateway (as opposed to Express Route). There are three different VPN gateway SKUs; we'll be doing the "Standard" offering (of Basic, Standard, High-Performance). It's worth having a read about the differences here.
  1. Navigate to "Virtual Network Gateways".


  2. Click "Add" and supply the following:
    • Name: Again, follow consistent naming standards.
    • Gateway Type: Select "VPN".
    • VPN type: Select "Route-Based" (packets routed by routing table) in this case; it would be advisable to familiarize yourself with the difference between route and policy here.
    • SKU: For this tutorial we'll be selecting "Standard". Select a different class if it suits your needs.
    • Virtual Network: Select the virtual network we created in the last step.
    • Public IP address: Select the IP address we created earlier.


  3. Click "Create".

Note: This step may take up to 45 minutes to complete provisioning. I've tracked 8 of these and it's averaging almost 40 minutes per regardless of if you pre-provision the IP or not. You may want to consider skipping ahead to the pfSense section for a bit and coming back here.


Local Network Gateway/Connection


A Local Network Gateway is the specification of our local IP and networks you would like to route over the tunnel. 

This actually works fine with a dynamic IP if that is your scenario, but we'll cover the details of that later.
  1. Navigate to "Local Network Gateways".


  2. Click "Add" and supply the following:
    • Name: Naming? Standards? Consistent? Yeah!
    • IP Address: Enter the public IP address of your device that will instantiate the tunnel.
    • Address Space: This is where you enter the CIDR notation of the local networks you would like to route over the tunnel... for example, if you would like to route 192.168.1.x over the tunnel, then enter "192.168.1.0/24"
    • Subscription: Enter your desired subscription.
    • Resource Group: Select our resource group we created above.
    • Location: For consistency, select the same location as you have selected above.


  3. Click "Create".
  4. After provisioning, (you may need to hit "refresh) click your newly created Local Network Gateway and click "Connections".


  5. On the newly expanded pane, click "Add" and supply the following:
    • Name: You know the drill by now.
    • Connection type: This should be fixed to "Site to Site (IPsec)"
    • Virtual Network Gateway: Enter the Virtual Network Gateway we entered in the step above.
    • Shared Key: Specify a unique, randomly generated passphrase comprised of alphanumeric characters. Some devices have issues with special characters, hence the omission of. I recommend using at least 30 characters; since it has no impact on tunnel performance I personally use at least 60 characters for each key. You'll need to specify this key on your local side as well.
    • Subscription: This should be hard coded to the same subscription as the LNG.
    • Resource Group: This also should be locked to the same resource group as the LNG.
    • Location: Locked to that of the LNG.


  6. Click "OK".

Configure pfSense


Now we'll set up the IPsec initiator connection on your pfSense firewall(s).

Phase 1 Setup

  1. Login to the firewall and navigate to "VPN->IPsec"
  2. Click "Add" and specify the following:
    • Key Exchange Version: Auto
    • Internet Protocol: IPv4
    • Interface: Select the WAN interface from which you would like to instantiate the connection
    • Remote Gateway: Enter the Azure public IP address created in the "Public IP Address" section above
    • Description: Whatever you would like; maybe troll your firewall team with a message here for fun times.
    • Authentication Method: Mutual PSK
    • Negotiation Mode: Main Note: Do not use "Aggressive" mode as the hash of the PSK is sent over the internet in clear text.
    • My Identifier: If the WAN interface selected above holds your public IP address, you can select "My IP Address". If that interface lies behind another edge device that holds the public IP, you'll need to select "IP Address" and specify your external IP.
    • Peer Identifier: Peer IP Address
    • Pre-Shared Key: Enter the same Pre-Shared Key used in the Azure connection specification above.
    • Encryption Algorithm: The strongest available in Azure is AES 256 bit, so preferably specify that. For more information on supported features in Azure, see the References section below.
    • Hashing Algorithm: The best we can do here is SHA256, so let's go with that.
    • DH Group: 2(1024 bit)
    • Lifetime (seconds): 10800
    • Disable Rekey: Unchecked
    • Responder Only: Unchecked
    • NAT Traversal: Auto (Even in NAT scenarios Auto usually works)
    • Dead Peer Detection: Checked
    • Delay: 10
    • Max Failures: 5


  3. Click "Save" to return to the "VPN->IPsec" menu.
  4. Since we don't want to use this yet, click "Disable" in front of the new tunnel definition and then "Apply Changes".

Phase 2 Setup

  1. Under our newly created tunnel definition, click "Show Phase 2 Entries"
  2. Click "Add P2" and supply the following information:
    • Disabled: Unchecked
    • Mode: Tunnel IPv4
    • Local Network: Select "Network" and specify the same network range(s) that you specified during the set up of the local network gateway on Azure using CIDR notation, i.e. 192.168.1.0/24. This specifies which local network(s) you would like to route through the tunnel.
    • NAT/BINAT translation: None  ; Note: even in scenarios where your pfSense device is using NAT behind an upstream router, this should not be necessary. NAT-T will take care of that scenario.
    • Remote Network: Select "Network" and specify the same network range(s) that you specified during the set up of the target virtual network in Azure using CIDR notation, i.e. 10.1.0.0/16. This specifies the remote network(s) present in Azure.
    • Description: Put something here to help you remember what all this fun stuff is about.
    • Protocol: ESP
    • Encryption Algorithms: Check only "AES" and "256 bits".
    • Hash Algorithms: Unfortunately Azure only supports "SHA1" at this time.
    • PFS Key Group: Azure documentation states that PFS groups are only supported when Azure acts as responder, and in this case it is being set up as the initiator. Oddly, I've actually had luck specifying DH Group 14, but there is no guarantee that will work. I'm going to stick with it but for this by the book exercise you'll need to select "off". Note: Because of this setting and the prior Hash Algorithm setting, I do not consider this tunnel secure against state-level or similarly equipped actors. If that is a concern you may wish to investigate alternatives. In less extreme cases, however, this can be considered relatively secure.
    • Lifetime: 3600
    • Automatically ping host: blank


  3. Click "Save".  
Note: Depending on your configuration it may be necessary to navigate to "VPN->IPsec->Advanced Settings" and check "Enable Maximum MSS", then specify 1350. If you get packet loss with large packets this setting may be needed.

Firewall Rules

Now that our tunnel is set up we have to create local firewall rules that allow for traffic to pass. First we'll create a network alias for the Azure side network and then we'll make a rule to allow out Azure based traffic to pass here.

  1. Navigate to "Firewall->Aliases"
  2. Click "Add" and supply the following:
    • Name: Supply something that explains this network is to represent the Azure side of the tunnel; only alphanumeric and "_" are allowed.
    • Description: Enter full description here; there are no special character limitations.
    • Type: "Network(s)"
    • Network(s): Enter the CIDR notation of the network you created for your Virtual Network in Azure. If you followed the example addresses in this article, that would be 10.1.0.0/16.
  3. Click "Save" and then "Apply Changes".
  4. Navigate to "Firewall->Rules->IPsec".
  5. Click "Add -^" and supply the following:
    • Action: "Pass"
    • Disable this rule: Unchecked
    • Interface: "IPsec"
    • Address Family: "IPv4"
    • Protocol: "Any"   Discussion: Feel free to limit the traffic that goes through the tunnel if you like. In this example I'm allowing all traffic through.
    • Source: "Single host or alias" and then specify the Azure network alias you created in step 2.
    • Destination: This needs to be the local network(s) to which you would like to allow traffic. You can either do "network" with a CIDR notation or specify the entire network represented by an interface on the firewall. Note: if you have multiple networks you'll need a rule for each, so repeat the last couple steps for each.
    • Log: Unchecked; keep in mind that should you need to troubleshoot temporarily logging traffic using this rule can be very useful.
    • Description: It's a description, so let's do that!
    • No advanced options necessary unless you would like to do so.
  6. Click "Save" and then "Apply Changes".


As long as you have a blanket egress traffic rule we should now be able to route traffic over the tunnel. If you do not I expect you are aware of how to make a more specific rule to suit your needs.

A Note on NAT-T and Upstream Routers

If your pfSense device is behind another upstream router, you may need some changes to facilitate the port switchover after initialization. If this matches your configuration, consider that you may need the following on the upstream router:
  • A firewall rule that allows UDP port 4500 into your pfSense device(s).
  • A NAT port mapping rule that forwards UDP port 4500 to your pfSense device(s).

Try without first; some devices are aware enough of the switch to 4500 to perform the transition without rules, but if it does not work consult the documentation for the device in question.


Enable and Test

There are several ways to test our connection; in this case I'll be pinging a VM host in Azure assigned to the same virtual network that this tunnel is connecting to. We won't go through the provisioning of that; should you need to refer to this basic guide and ensure you place the VM in your target virtual network and initially created subnet (10.1.10.x in the example above).

We're about to go into a tunnel... a long one.

Preparing Your Target

  • Ensure your VM is up and provisioned in the correct target virtual network.
  • Since you can't put anything in the gateway subnet (correctly) this would be a good opportunity to put the VM in the subnet you were forced to create when creating the virtual network in the first place. Check/change VM->Network interfaces->Details->Settings->IP Configurations
  • Get the private IP address from VM->Network interfaces. It should be 10.1.10.x if you're following the example addresses in this article.
  • Make sure your VM is pingable! If you have instituted Network Security Groups that would inhibit access you'll need to modify them, though this should work by default since we're tunneled in. Make sure the firewall on the VM allows for incoming ICMP requests as well; on Win 2012 and higher set-netfirewallrule -DisplayName "File and Printer Sharing (Echo Request - ICMPv4-In)" -Enabled True will take care of you.

Bring Up The Tunnel

  1. In the pfSense interface, navigate to VPN->IPsec.
  2. In front of our new tunnel, click "Enable" then "Apply" toward the top.
  3. Check tunnel status under Status->IPsec. The tunnel should come up automatically in about a minute. If there is trouble you can check the Status->System Logs->IPsec section for more details.

Check Tunnel Status in Azure & Ping Dat VM!

For this portion we'll use PowerShell; ensure you have the Azure ARM cmdlets installed. If not, give install-module AzureRM a shot from an elevated PowerShell prompt.

  1. Login to your account: Login-AzureRmAccount
  2. Look at your subscriptions and grab the name of the target sub: Get-AzureRmSubscription
  3. Change to your correct subscription: Select-AzureRmSubscription -SubscriptionName <subscription name>
  4. Check the status: Get-AzureRmVirtualNetworkGatewayConnection -name <Local Gateway Connection> -ResourceGroupName <Name of Resourcegroup to which it belongs>
  5. On the output pane, check the "ConnectionStatus" property. It should be "Connected".

The Get-AzureRmVirtualNetworkGatewayConnection has a series of other interesting properties as well, including EgressBytesTransferred and IngressBytesTransferred.

Now proceed to ping your VM by the private IP listed in Azure. As long as everything is configured correctly you should receive a response!


Cost

VPN Tunnels are subject to a costs from a few different categories:
  • VPN Gateway Pricing: This is an hourly cost incurred while the tunnel is available, not necessarily used. This means once it's provisioned you will incur charges at the hourly rate. As of the writing the standard performance level that we'll be using is billed at $0.19/hr in the US. If you have multiple Virtual Networks you will also be subject to a fee for outgoing traffic destined for another VNet. This rate depends on the zone and varies between $.035 and $.16 per GB. Data outbound to your site is charged at the standard data transfer rates (below) and inbound data is free.
  • Data Transfer Rates: This depends on your level of utilization. The first 5GB of outgoing/month is free and the prices are set on a curve thereafter.
  • Virtual Network Pricing: VNets are free; you can have up to 50 VNets per subscription across all regions.
  • IP Addresses: You'll be using at least one IP address. The first 5 static in a given region are free, additional and dynamic are charged at a rate of $.004/hr.

Overall the cost of a "standard" class data tunnel each month for a single IP address, no additional support, and without including outgoing bandwidth, is about $140/month. 

Note: Costs as of 10/26/2016, subject to change. Up to date pricing information is available here.


Dynamic IP? Changing Your IP Address

There is no reason that this IPsec tunnel will not work without a dnymic IP, but each time the IP changes you'll need to take a series of steps to restore tunnel functionality. These are:
  1. In Azure, the local network gateway specifies your IP, change it under "Local network gateway-><NAME>->Configuration->IP address".
  2. In pfSense, the Phase 1 tunnel definition under "My identifier" needs to reflect your current external IP address.
  3. If there are any implications on upstream  routers you'll need to handle that as well.

After taking care of these you will need to restart the tunnel. This could all be automated with PowerShell and SSH if you like, but I won't be covering that here.


A Note on Effective Security

As mentioned earlier, this set up does have a couple security issues; the impact of which I would like to discuss briefly. Without an optimal security configuration, including the support of Perfect Forward Secrecy, this tunnel may not be strong enough to stand up to attacks of a state-sponsored actor over a long period of time. Because of that I cannot recommend this solution if your traffic may be subject to that level of attack, for example traffic facilitating substantial financial transaction activity.

With that said, this tunnel is still (for better or worse) more secure than the configuration I have seen at many clients, and should be suitable for most traffic. It also performs very well; added latency between my modestly equipped pfSense devices and Azure is trivial.

For science!

References


Azure

Microsoft: Azure Virtual Network Overview
Microsoft: Azure Resource Manager Cmdlets (PowerShell)
Microsoft: Create a VNet with a Site-to-Site connection using the Azure portal
Microsoft: Create a VNet with a Site-to-Site connection using PowerShell
Steve Buchanan: Azure & RRAS Site to Site VPN Setup (Azure Resource Manager)
Microsoft: What is a Network Security Group?
Microsoft: VPN Gateway FAQ
Microsoft: About VPN Gateway
Microsoft: How to install and configure Azure PowerShell
Microsoft: About VPN Devices for Site-to-Site VPN Gateway Connections (Critical article; contains IPsec specs of Azure side)

pfSense

pfSense Doco: Routing internet traffic through a site-to-site IPsec tunnel
pfSense Doco: VPN Capability IPsec

IPsec

PFS RFC
strongSwan Wiki: Security recommendations
Johannes Webber: Considerations About IPsec Pre-Shared Keys
Cisco Support: How Does NAT-T Work With IPsec (Only needed if behind NAT)

2 comments:

Jesper Blak said...

Hey Toby

Thanks for at great article about this s2s between Azure and pfSense.
Your link 'Microsoft: About VPN Devices for Site-to-Site VPN Gateway Connections' was the missing link for me to get it work.

Sincerely Jesper

Andrew McAllister said...

Extremely helpful walkthrough, thank you!

We're running pfsense 2.2.4 and the IKE setting does not include auto. Just wanted to note that policy based vpn in Azure requires IKEv1 and route based requires IKEv2.


Sincerely,
Andrew